Should You Review Your Medicare Plan During Open Enrollment?
Yes — Medicare's Annual Open Enrollment period, which runs from October 15 to December 7 each year, is your yearly window to review your coverage and make changes for the coming year. Even if you're happy with your current plan, it's worth a careful look. Premiums, deductibles, drug formularies, and provider networks can all change from one year to the next, and a plan that fit you well when you enrolled may quietly become a poor fit for the year ahead.
For retirees and pre-retirees in Columbus, Ohio, Medicare is one of the largest and least predictable expenses in retirement. It also doesn't sit in its own box — your coverage choices connect to your income, your taxes, and your overall cash flow. As a fee-only fiduciary advisor, I help clients think through these decisions as part of the whole retirement picture, not in isolation.
This article walks through what Open Enrollment is, what you can and can't change, the six things worth reviewing every year, and the mistakes I most often see people make.
Quick Answer
Medicare Open Enrollment (October 15 – December 7) lets you switch between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage, change from one Medicare Advantage plan to another, and join, drop, or change a Part D prescription drug plan. Each fall, your plan sends an Annual Notice of Change describing what's changing for the coming year. Reviewing it matters because premiums, drug coverage, and networks can all shift — affecting both your coverage and your budget. Any changes you make during this window generally take effect January 1.
Key Takeaways
- Open Enrollment runs October 15 to December 7; changes generally take effect January 1.
- Read your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) and Evidence of Coverage (EOC) — they spell out exactly what's changing in your current plan.
- Six areas are worth reviewing every year: premiums, drug coverage, provider network, plan benefits, total yearly cost, and your own health needs.
- "No change" is a decision too — letting a plan auto-renew without reviewing can quietly cost you if the plan's terms shifted.
- The lowest premium is not always the lowest total cost once you factor in your prescriptions and how you actually use care.
- Medicare decisions connect to income and tax planning, including IRMAA surcharges driven by income from two years prior.
- I'm not an insurance agent and don't sell Medicare plans; I help you think through the decision as part of your overall retirement plan and coordinate with licensed resources for enrollment.
Table of Contents
- What is Medicare Open Enrollment?
- How is this different from other Medicare enrollment periods?
- What can you change during this window?
- Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage: what's the real difference?
- Why review your plan even if you're satisfied?
- Six things to check every year
- How does Medicare connect to the rest of your retirement plan?
- What this looks like for a Columbus retiree
- Common mistakes to avoid
- How I help
- FAQs
What Is Medicare Open Enrollment?
Medicare's Annual Open Enrollment period — sometimes called the Annual Election Period, or AEP — runs from October 15 through December 7 every year. It's the main window when most people already enrolled in Medicare can review their coverage and make changes for the following year.
Think of it as Medicare's yearly reset. Plans are allowed to change their terms each calendar year, and this is the window built into the system for you to respond to those changes. Whatever you decide during this period — including deciding to do nothing — sets your coverage for the next twelve months, generally starting January 1.
The reason it exists is simple: Medicare plans are annual contracts. The premium, the drug list, the cost-sharing, and the network are all set for one year at a time. Open Enrollment is your chance to make sure the contract you'll be in next year still matches your life.
How Is This Different From Other Medicare Enrollment Periods?
Medicare has several enrollment windows, and mixing them up is one of the most common sources of confusion. Here's how they fit together:
| Enrollment Period | When | What It's For |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Enrollment Period | The 7-month window around your 65th birthday | Signing up for Medicare for the first time |
| Annual Open Enrollment (AEP) | October 15 – December 7 | The broadest set of yearly changes (the focus of this article) |
| Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment | January 1 – March 31 | A more limited window to change Advantage plans or return to Original Medicare |
| Special Enrollment Periods | Triggered by life events | Moving, losing other coverage, and similar situations |
The October–December window is the big one because it offers the widest range of choices. If you want to make a meaningful change to your coverage for next year, this is almost always the window to do it in.
What Can You Change During This Window?
During Annual Open Enrollment, you can generally:
- Switch from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan, or from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare.
- Change from one Medicare Advantage plan to another.
- Join a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan.
- Switch from one Part D plan to another.
- Drop your Part D coverage entirely (though going without creditable drug coverage can create a lifelong penalty, so this is rarely wise).
Any changes you make during this period generally take effect on January 1 of the following year.
One important note: Medigap (Medicare Supplement) coverage follows different rules and is not tied to this window. Buying or switching a Medigap policy can involve medical underwriting depending on your timing and your state, which makes it a separate conversation with its own considerations. If you have Original Medicare plus a Medigap policy, this window is mostly about your Part D drug plan.
Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage: What's the Real Difference?
Because Open Enrollment lets you move between the two, it helps to understand what you'd actually be choosing between. This is a simplified comparison — the details matter and vary by plan — but it frames the decision:
| Feature | Original Medicare (+ Medigap + Part D) | Medicare Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Doctor/hospital access | Any provider that accepts Medicare, nationwide | Usually a network; often HMO or PPO |
| Referrals for specialists | Generally not required | Often required (plan-dependent) |
| Drug coverage | Separate Part D plan | Usually built in |
| Predictability of costs | More predictable with Medigap | Copays vary by service; annual out-of-pocket cap |
| Extra benefits (dental, vision, etc.) | Not included | Often included |
| Monthly premium | Medigap premium can be higher | Often low or $0 premium (costs shift to when you use care) |
Neither is universally better. Original Medicare with a Medigap policy tends to offer broad access and predictable costs at a higher monthly premium. Medicare Advantage often has a low premium and extra benefits, but concentrates costs at the point of care and uses networks. The right fit depends on your health, your providers, your prescriptions, how often you travel, and your comfort with cost variability. Open Enrollment is when you can act on that fit.
Why Review Your Plan Even If You're Satisfied?
This is the step people most often skip. If nothing went wrong last year, it's tempting to let the coverage roll over and move on. The problem is that your plan can change even when your life doesn't.
Every fall, your plan sends two documents. The Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) summarizes what's changing for the coming year — the premium, the deductible, the drugs the plan covers and their tiers, and sometimes the network. The Evidence of Coverage (EOC) is the longer, detailed version. These usually arrive in September, before Open Enrollment opens, precisely so you have time to review them.
A plan that was an excellent fit when you enrolled can quietly become a poor one if:
- Your monthly premium increased.
- A prescription you take moved to a higher cost tier — or off the formulary entirely.
- Your doctor or a preferred hospital left the network.
- The deductible or copays rose.
- An extra benefit you valued was reduced or dropped.
Reviewing doesn't mean you have to switch. Often the right answer is to stay put. But it should be a decision you make on purpose after looking — not one that happens to you by default.
What Six Things Should You Check Every Year?
When I sit down with clients during this window, we look at the same six areas. These are the spokes in the graphic above, and they're the questions worth answering before you decide.
- Premiums. What will you pay each month next year, and has it changed? A premium increase alone isn't a reason to switch, but it's the starting point.
- Drug coverage. Are your specific prescriptions still covered, and on what tier? Formularies change every year, and this is where the most expensive surprises hide. It's worth checking each medication by name against next year's plan.
- Provider network. Are your doctors, specialists, and preferred Central Ohio hospitals still in-network for next year? Networks change, and an out-of-network provider can mean much higher costs — or a search for a new doctor.
- Plan benefits. Have deductibles, copays, or coinsurance shifted? Have any extra benefits — dental, vision, hearing, fitness — been added, reduced, or dropped?
- Total yearly cost. Not just the premium, but premium plus expected out-of-pocket costs for the way you actually use care. A low-premium plan with high copays can cost more overall than a higher-premium plan if you use care frequently.
- Your health needs. Have your prescriptions, providers, or health situation changed over the past year in a way your current plan doesn't serve as well? The best plan is the one that fits the way you'll use care next year — not the way you used it when you first signed up.
How Does Medicare Connect to the Rest of Your Retirement Plan?
Medicare doesn't sit in its own box. Your healthcare costs are part of your retirement cash flow, and — importantly — your income affects your Medicare premiums.
Higher income can trigger IRMAA, the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, which raises your Part B and Part D premiums. Two features of IRMAA catch people off guard:
- It's based on your income from two years prior, so a decision you make this year can raise your premiums two years later.
- It works on thresholds (income "cliffs"), meaning going even slightly over a bracket can bump you into a higher premium tier for the whole year.
That means a large IRA withdrawal, a Roth conversion, a big capital gain, or a one-time income event can quietly raise your Medicare premiums down the road. This is exactly why I don't treat Medicare planning as separate from income and tax planning. When we look at withdrawal strategy, Roth conversions, and RMDs, IRMAA thresholds are part of the same conversation. Coordinating those decisions — rather than making them one at a time — is where a lot of the value is.
What Does This Look Like for a Columbus Retiree?
Consider a retiree in Central Ohio who has been on the same Medicare Advantage plan for three years and is happy with it. This fall, the ANOC arrives and, on a quick read, the premium looks about the same, so it's tempting to file it away.
But a closer review turns up two things: one of their maintenance prescriptions has moved to a higher tier, and their longtime specialist is no longer listed in next year's network. Neither change is dramatic on its own, but together they could add up to real money and disruption over the year. Because they reviewed during Open Enrollment, they have time to compare alternatives, confirm which plans keep their doctor and cover their drugs affordably, and make a deliberate choice before December 7 — rather than discovering the changes at the pharmacy counter or the doctor's office in January.
That's the whole point of the review: not to switch for its own sake, but to make sure the plan you'll be in next year still fits the life you're actually living.
What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid?
- Letting coverage auto-renew without reading the ANOC. The plan may have changed even if you didn't.
- Choosing a plan on premium alone. The lowest premium isn't always the lowest total cost once you factor in your prescriptions and how you use care.
- Forgetting to check the drug formulary by name. A covered medication can move to a higher tier — or off the list — from one year to the next.
- Assuming your doctors are always in-network. Networks change; confirm your specific providers each year.
- Ignoring the IRMAA connection. Income decisions this year can raise Medicare premiums two years from now.
- Missing the December 7 deadline. Outside this window, your options to change are limited.
- Dropping Part D to save money. Going without creditable drug coverage can create a permanent late-enrollment penalty.
How I Help
I'm not an insurance agent, and I don't sell Medicare plans or earn commissions on them. What I do is help you think through the decision the way a fiduciary should — as one piece of your broader retirement plan.
That means looking at how your plan choice fits with your cash flow, how your income decisions affect IRMAA, and how healthcare costs factor into the years ahead. I help you frame the six questions above, understand the trade-offs between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage for your situation, and see how it all connects to your withdrawal and tax strategy. For the plan-specific comparison and the enrollment itself, I coordinate with licensed resources so the details are handled correctly. My role is to make sure the choice makes sense in the context of everything else — because in retirement, almost every decision is connected to the others.
FAQs
When is Medicare Open Enrollment in 2026?
October 15 through December 7. Changes you make generally take effect January 1, 2027.
Do I have to make a change during Open Enrollment?
No. If your plan still fits after you review it, you can keep it. The point is to review before deciding, not to switch for its own sake.
What's the difference between Open Enrollment and Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment?
The Annual Open Enrollment period (October 15 – December 7) offers the broadest set of changes. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 – March 31) is separate and more limited — it's mainly for people already in an Advantage plan who want to change it or return to Original Medicare.
What is an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC)?
It's the document your plan sends each fall (usually in September) that summarizes what's changing in your plan for the coming year — premium, deductible, drug coverage, and sometimes network. Reading it is the single most useful thing you can do before Open Enrollment.
Does this window apply to Medigap plans?
Medigap (Medicare Supplement) follows different rules and isn't tied to this window. Buying or changing Medigap can involve medical underwriting depending on timing and state, so it's a separate conversation.
How does my income affect my Medicare premiums?
Through IRMAA, higher income can raise your Part B and Part D premiums. It's based on your income from two years prior and works on thresholds, so income decisions today can affect premiums later. This is why Medicare and tax planning belong in the same conversation.
Can you sell me a Medicare plan?
No. I'm a fee-only fiduciary advisor, not an insurance agent. I help you think through how a plan fits your overall retirement picture and coordinate with licensed resources for enrollment.
Please use the link below to schedule a call with me.
https://calendly.com/jimblue/blue-advisors-meeting
By James Blue, Fee-Only Advisor | Blue Advisors
James Blue is the founder of Blue Advisors, a fee-only financial planning and investment management firm based in Columbus, Ohio.
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Blue Advisors is a fee-only registered investment advisory firm and is not an insurance agency; we do not sell Medicare plans or earn commissions on insurance products. Medicare rules, enrollment dates, plan details, and IRMAA thresholds are set by the federal government and individual plans and are subject to change; confirm current details at Medicare.gov. The views expressed are those of the author as of the date published and are subject to change without notice. Advisory services are offered only pursuant to a written advisory agreement and to clients in the State of Ohio, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and other jurisdictions where Blue Advisors is properly registered or exempt from registration. Please consult with your financial advisor, tax professional, or a licensed Medicare resource before making decisions about your coverage.